Sustainable Investing Decoded

Sustainable investing can be a meaningful way to align your values with your investments, particularly if environmental or social values are important to you. Read on to learn about the types of sustainable investing and whether one or more might be right for you.

 The sustainable investing spectrum

The term “sustainable investing” refers to three types of investments:

  • ESG: Environmental, Social and Governance
  • SRI: Socially Responsible Investing
  • Impact Investing

Together, they bridge the gap between conventional investing, where financial return is the priority, and philanthropy, where a social outcome is the priority.

ESG: Environmental, Social, and Governance

ESG is appealing to investors who want to support companies that align with their values, without sacrificing the financial return that can be gained by investing a broad market index like the S&P 500 or Russell 3000 (a total US stock market index).

ESG funds seek to maximize financial return by favoring companies with positive environmental, social and governance characteristics, and excluding the worst offenders in each sector.

This works for two reasons. First, companies with strong ESG practices generally perform better. We know this because the data is there. As of 2023, 85% of large cap companies (like those in the S&P 500 or Russell 1000 indices) report their greenhouse gas emissions. Reporting on social and governance criteria has also increased substantially in recent years. Higher ESG performance correlates with stronger market performance.

Second, because ESG funds don’t exclude entire sectors, but rather avoid the worst offenders in each sector and reward companies with good ESG practices, they are able to maintain similar diversification to the indices they track, for example the S&P 500 or Russell 3000.

Environmental criteria like carbon emissions, water use and pollution are often key criteria for ESG funds. In addition, ESG funds commonly exclude companies that earn meaningful revenue from things like factory farming, child labor, coal, tobacco, and a range of weapon types.

Takeaway: ESG can be a win-win first step into sustainable investing.

Examples of ESG funds:

  • iShares MSCI KLD 400 Social ETF (DSI). Established in 2006, this ETF contains large, mid and small cap stocks. It tracks the MSCI KLD 400 Social Index, with performance comparable to the Russell 3000 over the past 1, 3, 5 and 10 years (data as of 12/31/2024).
  • Vanguard ESG US Stock ETF (ESGV). Established in 2018, this ETF contains large, mid and small cap stocks. It tracks the FTSE US All-Cap Choice Index and has performed comparable to the Russell 3000 over the past 1, 3 and 5 years (data as of 12/31/2024).

SRI: Socially Responsible Investing

SRI is appealing to investors who prefer to exclude companies or entire sectors whose products or practices conflict with their personal values. Some of the original SRI funds appealed to ethical investors with blanket exclusions of “sin” stocks, such as companies in the alcohol, tobacco, pornography, gambling or firearms businesses. Some religious groups maintain SRI funds that align with their teachings and values, and investors who wish to exclude companies that harm animals in any way can do so through SRI investments.

SRI investments seek to balance social outcomes with financial return.  Returns may be lower than with ESG investments, because SRI can exclude entire sectors, some of which may be high-growth or very profitable. To the committed SRI investor, this is a tradeoff worth making.

Takeaway: SRI goes beyond ESG to exclude companies or sectors that conflict with the investor’s values. The social outcome takes priority over financial return.

Example of an SRI fund:

  • US Vegan Climate ETF (VEGN). Established in 2019, this fund screens large-cap companies for ESG considerations, primarily animal harm and exploitation, fossil fuels, environmental damage and human rights. It tracks both the Beyond Investing US Climate Index and the S&P 500.

Impact Investing

Impact investing is appealing to investors who wish to use their money to invest in solutions that can drive measurable outcomes. Like philanthropy, impact investing’s objective is to address a social or environmental problem. The difference is that impact investors use their capital to invest in or establish businesses that generate revenue that can be reinvested in the business to strengthen and expand its ability to address the problem over the long term.

For example, instead of donating food, an impact investor might invest in a local farm, with the agreement that profits are re-invested in that farm to expand its reach and range of products for the local community. As this example suggests, the impact investor often must be comfortable with having their money tied up for a long period of time.

Of the three types of sustainable investing, impact investing is the most concerned with driving targeted, measurable outcomes and the least concerned with financial returns.

Takeaway: Impact investing seeks to drive specific social or environmental outcomes through long-term investment with lower priority on personal financial return.

Ways to begin impact investing

  • Crowdfunding Platforms like Kiva and SeedInvest seek funding from individual investors to support social enterprises
  • Direct Investment Funds: Calvert Impact’s Community Investment Note is a fixed income security that channels capital to a diversified portfolio of organizations that target inequality and climate change

 

The Bottom Line

Sustainable investing can be an effective way to align one’s values with their money, particularly for those who prioritize environmental or social values. If this sounds like you, the first step is to decide which approach is right for you:

  • Do you want to feel good about your investments, without trading off returns? If so, ESG may be worth exploring.
  • Are you averse to investing in companies or sectors that conflict with your values? If so, talk to your advisor about SRI options.
  • Does the idea of driving measurable outcomes through investment excite you? If so, you may enjoy learning more about impact investing.